When discussing some of the rough patches in Buffalo Bills history, the name Nathan Peterman often comes up due to his infamous five-interception performance and short stint with the team. However, there may have been a quarterback even less successful: Gary Marangi.
Marangi, a third-round pick in the 1974 NFL Draft out of Boston College, was expected to bring value to the Bills. Instead, his time with the team turned out to be highly disappointing. Playing only three seasons in the NFL, all with Buffalo, Marangi posted a completion rate of just 36.7%, with 1,373 passing yards, 12 touchdowns, and 21 interceptions. Most notably, he went 0-7 as a starter in 1976.
That season stands out not only for Marangi’s struggles but also because it marked the last great year for legendary running back O.J. Simpson, who rushed for 1,503 yards and 8 touchdowns. Marangi’s performance is often seen as a wasted opportunity during what was Simpson’s final Pro Bowl and All-Pro campaign.
While Peterman is often remembered for his poor play, it’s worth noting that he was a fifth-round pick and only started briefly. In contrast, Marangi, as a higher draft pick and full-time starter, arguably had a more detrimental impact during his tenure.
Though both quarterbacks represent low points for the franchise, Marangi’s stats and missed potential suggest he may deserve the title of the worst quarterback in Bills history.
About the Author
