The conclusion of the World Series marks the beginning of another high-stakes contest: the MLB offseason. For the Philadelphia Phillies, a team perched on the precipice of championship glory, the coming months represent a critical juncture. While the free agency of stars like Kyle Schwarber and J.T. Realmuto will dominate headlines, a more subtle and complex narrative is unfolding behind the scenes. According to a report by Todd Zolecki of MLB.com, the Phillies’ front office, led by President of Baseball Operations Dave Dombrowski, is contemplating a strategic shift that involves exploring the trade market for several core, homegrown, and immensely popular players. This potential strategy, which includes names like Alec Bohm, Bryson Stott, Brandon Marsh, and Matt Strahm, alongside the widely anticipated departure of Nick Castellanos, signals a proactive and potentially ruthless approach to building a perennial contender.
The most straightforward case among the trade candidates is that of Nick Castellanos. His potential departure is less a rumor and more an accepted inevitability within baseball circles. Zolecki went so far as to say it would be “surprising” to see Castellanos in red pinstripes next season. The logic is rooted in financial pragmatism and roster construction. Castellanos is expected to decline his $20 million player option for 2025 to seek a longer-term deal, likely his last significant contract. For the Phillies, who have a staggering $173 million committed to just four players (Bryce Harper, Trea Turner, Zack Wheeler, and Realmuto) in 2025, allocating more long-term capital to an aging, defensively limited slugger may be a luxury they cannot afford. His departure, whether via trade or free agency, clears a significant chunk of payroll and opens the designated hitter spot, providing the lineup with much-needed flexibility.
The situation with Alec Bohm is one of unfinished business and looming deadlines. The Phillies have reportedly tried to trade Bohm before, and those conversations are almost certain to resurface this winter. The primary driver is his contract status; 2025 is his final year of arbitration before he reaches free agency. Bohm has been a polarizing figure—a hitter with undeniable clutch ability and a high batting average, but whose lack of over-the-fence power for a corner infield spot and historically shaky defense have left the organization wanting more. Trading him now allows the Phillies to capitalize on his value as a proven, cost-controlled Major League bat rather than risk losing him for nothing after a walk year or facing the dilemma of a costly extension. It is a classic “sell-high” scenario on a player whose perceived value may never be higher.
However, the most intriguing and emotionally charged discussions surround Bryson Stott and Brandon Marsh. These are not underperforming veterans but homegrown talents who have become integral parts of the team’s identity. Stott, a smooth-fielding infielder, and Marsh, a charismatic, hair-flowing center fielder, are precisely the type of players fans embrace. Yet, from a cold, analytical front-office perspective, their trade candidacy is rooted in a confluence of factors: timing, performance, and organizational depth.
Both Stott and Marsh are entering what is often the most volatile period of a player’s team control—the final two years before free agency. This is the window where teams must decide: extend them to a long-term deal or trade them to maximize return. While both have been solid contributors, neither has blossomed into a bonafide star. Stott’s offense has been steady but unspectacular, while Marsh, despite improvements, still struggles with strikeouts and has yet to consistently hit left-handed pitching. The Phillies’ belief that they can upgrade these positions is bolstered by a rising tide of prospect talent. In the minors, infielder Aidan Miller and outfielder Justin Crawford represent the next wave—high-ceiling, toolsy players who are rapidly advancing. Trading Stott or Marsh now could be a preemptive strike, moving established but replaceable talent to acquire pitching or a star-level bat, all while clearing a path for a potentially superior and cheaper prospect in the near future. This is the kind of forward-thinking, sometimes painful, roster management that sustains championship windows.
The inclusion of Matt Strahm in trade talks is the most nuanced of the group. Unlike the others, his potential availability is not a commentary on his performance. On the contrary, Strahm has been arguably the Phillies’ most reliable and versatile reliever over the past two seasons, serving as a high-leverage lefty who can also provide spot starts. Trading him would be a pure baseball gamble. With one year remaining on his contract, his value on the market is high. The rationale would be to leverage that value to acquire a player with more long-term control or to address a more pressing need, betting that the front office can find a suitable, and perhaps cheaper, replacement for the bullpen. It is a high-risk maneuver, as proven, dependable relievers are a coveted commodity, and losing one could create a significant hole in a critical area.
This potential firesale of fan favorites points to a broader, more ambitious strategy by Dave Dombrowski. Known for his “win-now” aggressiveness, Dombrowski is also demonstrating a keen awareness of the team’s competitive lifecycle. The core of Harper, Turner, Wheeler, and Realmuto is not getting any younger. The window for a World Series title is wide open, but it is not infinite. Standing pat with a roster that has come close but fallen short is a path to stagnation. By being willing to move valuable, popular players like Bohm, Stott, and Marsh, Dombrowski is signaling a desire to re-tool on the fly.
The potential targets linked to the Phillies—such as Ketel Marte or Jarren Duran—are not lateral moves; they are clear upgrades. Swapping out Stott for a switch-hitting MVP candidate like Marte or replacing Marsh with a dynamic leadoff hitter like Duran would represent a significant offensive jolt. These are the kinds of bold transactions that can push a very good team over the top into a great one.
the Phillies’ offseason is shaping up to be defined by difficult goodbyes and strategic calculus. The emotional connection fans have with players like Stott and Marsh is real and valuable, but in the ruthless arithmetic of championship team building, sentimentality is a luxury. By exploring the trade market for these five players, Dave Dombrowski is not dismantling the team; he is attempting to engineer its next, more potent iteration. He is betting that the short-term pain of losing popular homegrown talent will be eclipsed by the long-term gain of a more complete, more dynamic roster capable of finally securing the World Series title that has eluded them. The success or failure of this high-wire act will define the Phillies’ trajectory for years to come.
About the Author
