The St. Louis Cardinals could decide to part ways with manager Oli Marmol, even if they make the playoffs this year. The team has outperformed expectations, partly because of Marmol’s steady approach and willingness to shield his players publicly despite mistakes that might justify criticism. He’s kept his composure better than he has in the past, and that’s helped the team.
However, a change in the front office could put Marmol’s job at risk regardless of results. Just like Mike Shildt was let go after taking the team to the postseason, Marmol might face the same outcome, though for different reasons. Despite his flaws, he’s guided a team that was expected tostruggle to a surprisingly strong season. The front office had signaled last winter that the club would likely take a step back, but they’ve done better than expected.
No one really knows what direction the Cardinals will take next because of the power balance between John Mozeliak and Chaim Bloom. Mozeliak won’t make big moves without Bloom’s approval, and Bloom prefers to decide on players who could impact the roster long-term. That leaves questions about trades and roster construction. While some stars like Nolan Arenado or Ryan Helsley could be moved, others like Brendan Donovan are reportedly off the table for now, as Bloom wants to handle that himself. Donovan made the All-Star Game and was the only NL player with two hits, which should count for something.
Team executives ultimately answer to the DeWitt family, who have been clear about wanting to cut payroll in the coming years. While this season’s success is encouraging, ownership doesn’t see this roster as a real title threat and may push for big changes.
That puts Marmol in a tough spot. The front office must decide if he’s the right fit to guide a younger team through a rebuild. He’s done well this year, but with veterans like Arenado and Miles Mikolas still providing leadership, it’s unclear if Marmol can maintain the same atmosphere if those leaders are traded. It’s a lot to ask, but it may be what’s expected.
Chaim Bloom has a history of making big, unpopular moves to reshape teams, as he did in Boston. To succeed in St. Louis, he’ll need to balance bold moves with the franchise’s culture — and it’s uncertain if Marmol fits that plan.
About the Author
