Cody Bellinger has quickly become a crucial part of the Yankees’ success this season. In just five days, he made a game-saving defensive play and crushed three home runs in a single game, helping the team to a five-game winning streak. If he wasn’t already a fan favorite, he certainly is now, and many are wondering what his future in New York might look like.
Bellinger holds a player option for 2026, but if he keeps performing like this, he’ll likely decline it to pursue a bigger deal. His versatility in the outfield and at first base, his left-handed power bat, and his improved strikeout rate have made him a perfect fit for the Yankees’ lineup. He’s also proven to be reliable in clutch moments, batting over .300 with runners in scoring position.
Beyond the stats, Bellinger handles New York well. He doesn’t shy away from pressure, connects easily with the media, and has a childhood link to the team that makes a long-term stay even more appealing to fans.
Looking ahead, the Yankees should consider extending him before he hits free agency. He’s currently earning $27.5 million, and a reasonable extension might be around five years for $140 million — an amount that fits the team’s current payroll structure alongside stars like Aaron Judge and Gerrit Cole.
With talented young players already in the system, the Yankees can afford to spend to keep their core together instead of chasing expensive free agents. Bellinger’s impact and smooth fit in New York make a new deal worth serious consideration before the offseason arrives.
About the Author
