The Chicago Cubs’ series opener against the St. Louis Cardinals didn’t go as planned, particularly for starting pitcher Ben Brown. Brown allowed nine hits over five innings, including four home runs, while striking out only three and walking two. This rough outing was one of several inconsistent performances from him this season, ultimately leading to his demotion to Triple-A Iowa the following day.
Despite frustration from fans and critical reactions online, manager Craig Counsell provided a more measured response. Counsell emphasized that struggles are part of the development process for young pitchers. He noted that while it’s hard to see progress during tough times, these moments are often when the most growth occurs. His supportive comments reflect a commitment to Brown’s long-term development rather than a quick fix.
Brown’s season has been marked by inconsistency—dominating in some starts while falling apart in others. A key factor is his reliance on just two pitches, which requires pinpoint accuracy. When his command falters, opposing hitters capitalize quickly. A comparison between his strong outing against the Reds on May 31 and the recent Cardinals game shows a major difference in pitch location, especially the costly “middle-middle” mistakes that led to home runs.
One particularly problematic pitch was a high change-up hit out by Alec Burleson. This offering, intended to add depth to Brown’s arsenal, needs refinement and better placement—something more suited to development time in the minors. Working through these issues in Triple-A allows Brown to improve without the pressure of big-league competition or a tight playoff race.
Brown’s demotion should be viewed as a chance for him to reset and adjust, not as a sign the organization is giving up on him. While some might see potential for him in a bullpen role, the Cubs are still committed to giving him opportunities as a starter. Whether he returns later this season or in the future, the hope is that time in Iowa will prepare Brown to contribute more consistently when the Cubs need him most.
