Yankees Face Infield Logjam as Jazz Chisholm Return
The Yankees’ acquisition of Jazz Chisholm Jr. at last year’s trade deadline provided an immediate boost, adding elite infield defense, speed, and left-handed power. Though primarily a second baseman, he adapted seamlessly to third base—a necessity after Gleyber Torres refused to shift from second. Chisholm’s 2025 season started slowly (.181/.304/.410) before an oblique injury sidelined him in late April.
In his absence, DJ LeMahieu, Oswald Peraza, and Jorbit Vivas have rotated at second and third base. Vivas’ struggles (.154 AVG, -0.1 WAR) likely make him the odd man out, leaving LeMahieu and Chisholm to compete for playing time upon the latter’s return. Both prefer second base but are capable at third, forcing manager Aaron Boone into a tough decision.
LeMahieu, 36, carries pedigree as a two-time batting champion but hasn’t been fully healthy since 2021. Injuries and age raise questions about his current offensive ceiling. Meanwhile, Peraza has flashed Gold Glove-caliber defense at third but continues to underwhelm at the plate, leaving his long-term role uncertain.
Despite the infield puzzle, the Yankees remain in strong position (33-20, +111 run differential), allowing them to patiently evaluate their options. Chisholm’s return timeline remains unclear, as he has yet to begin a rehab assignment. The coming weeks will determine whether LeMahieu’s veteran presence or Chisholm’s dynamic skill set wins out in the lineup.
