Extending Courtland Sutton Would Be a Major Mistake for the Broncos
The Denver Broncos face a decision on wide receiver Courtland Sutton’s contract, and extending him at a high price could be a serious misstep. While Sutton is a solid contributor and has built early chemistry with rookie quarterback Bo Nix, he’s not a true No. 1 receiver. His value is clear, but the team must be cautious about overcommitting.
Bob Morris of Broncos on SI recently projected a possible extension: four years, $98 million with $52 million in full guarantees—an average of $24.5 million per year. The deal would include a significant signing bonus and full guarantees through at least 2026, possibly into 2027. This structure would give Sutton more money upfront, in addition to the $14 million he is already set to earn in 2025.
Morris compared Sutton’s potential deal to recent contracts signed by:
- Michael Pittman Jr.: 3 years, $68 million
- Calvin Ridley: 4 years, $92 million
- Nico Collins: 3 years, $72.75 million
Based on those numbers, Morris suggests Sutton’s value could justify a near $100 million deal. However, the article argues this would be an excessive overpayment. Given Sutton’s production—only two 1,000-yard seasons in his career—it’s hard to justify such a commitment, especially considering he’s not seen as a top-tier receiver.
The Broncos might be better served using those resources to extend key defenders like Zach Allen or John Franklin-Myers. There’s speculation that a deal for pass rusher Nik Bonitto might also be in the works.
While re-signing Sutton makes some sense, the team must draw a line financially. If the asking price climbs toward $100 million, the smart move may be to walk away.
