Rob Thomson seems to be growing tired of the constant discussion about the Phillies’ lineup. The debate over the batting order has been ongoing for the last two seasons, especially after Kyle Schwarber’s impressive performance leading off games last year, where he hit a record 15 home runs in the leadoff spot. Despite his success, the idea of switching him out for Trea Turner, known for his speed and high on-base percentage, was also considered. Turner’s ability to apply pressure with his speed made him a strong candidate for the top spot, but Thomson decided to ease the debate by announcing that the Phillies will rotate between the two players depending on the opposing pitcher.
Thomson clarified that Turner will lead off when facing left-handed pitchers, while Schwarber will continue in the leadoff spot against right-handed pitchers. This strategy was first implemented during the Opening Day game against the Washington Nationals, where Turner led off with a left-handed pitcher on the mound. Despite the Phillies striking out 19 times in the game, the new lineup was effective, with the top four hitters contributing significantly to the team’s offensive output.
However, there were concerns in the lower half of the lineup, particularly with Bryson Stott and Brandon Marsh, who struggled against left-handed pitching last season. Marsh’s performance in the opener, with four strikeouts, could be a worrying sign, especially since Thomson plans to start him every day, regardless of the pitcher. As the season progresses, it will be important to monitor how these players perform in this new batting order.
